Thursday, March 28, 2024

Rafa Benitez – Clever tactics or just ‘losing it’?

I was going to write today’s article about the unbelievable Joe Kinnear, but have decided that Rafa Benitez is even more worthy of comment at this time!

Poor decision

The reason Kinnear came into the picture was his comments after the 1-1 draw with Sunderland. The visitors were 1-0 up when Newcastle were awarded the softest of penalties to allow them to escape with a draw. It was a very poor decision and Newcastle were very lucky to get the penalty.

What does Kinnear say after the game? He has moaned a lot about referees so far, so presumably he will say that they got lucky this time, but that it was about time, or something like that. No, he said,

“There were turning points in the game and I don’t think – again – the big decisions have gone our way, but that’s the way it is going for us at the moment.”

As I say. Unbelievable.

Questionnable behaviour

Then the Robbie Keane saga continued and I felt it only right that the slightly questionable behaviour of Rafa Benitez over recent weeks should be looked at.

Whether you believe that Harry Redknapp tapped Robbie Keane up, or Benitez never wanted him in the first place, or Keane was treated poorly or nobody is to blame and it was just one of those things, the sale of Keane back to Tottenham was an embarrassing day for Liverpool FC.

Well respected

The facts of the matter are that a well respected Premier League and international player went to the club for £20 million and has been sold back to where he came from six months later for just £12 million. Whichever way you look at that, it is not good.

In recent times Rafa has come under a great deal of scrutiny. Much of it has been of his own making. Some say that he has been ‘doing a Mourinho’ and trying to deflect pressure away from his players. Some say he has been ‘doing a Ferguson’ and trying to play mind games and creating a ‘them and us’ situation. Others say simply that Rafa has ‘lost it’

At the risk of jumping on a growing bandwagon, I have to say that I think I fall into the category of people who feel that Rafa has somewhat let the pressure get to him and that he may indeed have ‘lost it’.

More importantly

The fans still seem to be behind their manager but the absolute need to win either the Champions League or more importantly, the Premier League, is growing by the day.

The manager’s team selection, particularly in Premier League games has always been confusing to the outsider. I see the likes of Agger, Babel and up until a couple of days ago, Robbie Keane, struggling to get a game whilst the likes of Benayoun, Kuyt and Lucas are regular fixtures in the side. I appreciate Benitez sees them more than me and knows more about football than me, but I’m not the only one who finds these decisions strange.

Defensive and cautious

It is well reported that Benitez has a defensive and cautious nature. His desire to play with two holding midfielders seems to be unshakeable and will always lead to a team that is hard to beat rather than a team that goes for the jugular.

Even on Sunday against Chelsea, with the score at 0-0 and the visitors down to ten men, in what everyone believed was a must win game, Benitez left it until the 83rd minute before sacrificing one of his holding players, Mascherano, for the more attacking Babel. OK, the two late goals brought the win and his decision was justified, but it was a worrying example of the man’s caution.

Spotlight

The incidents that have put Benitez in the spotlight are the attack he made on Sir Alex Ferguson which whilst being relatively controlled and probably wrongly referred to as a rant, was almost certainly ill advised at best.

The attack on Everton for playing defensively against them at Anfield. They played in a similar way to that which Benitez has so successfully used for Liverpool in Europe. Everton go to Anfield to take on a more talented Liverpool side. How do they play? They play in exactly the same way Liverpool would play if they went to the Camp Nou to take on a more talented Barcelona side.

The description of the events of the second half in the 1-1 draw at Wigan as being ‘crazy’, but then not being prepared to expand on his comments. Just what on earth was he talking about?

Hypocrisy

The complaint about the ‘tapping up’ of Robbie Keane by Harry Redknapp. This one really does smack of total hypocrisy. The purchase of Keane in the first place and more obviously, the pursuit of Gareth Barry, were far more obvious cases of ‘tapping up’ in my opinion.

In other words, I think at the moment that everything Benitez is saying publicly is open to question. Did he want Robbie Keane in the first place? If he did, then his current demands for total control over transfers seem to be difficult to justify in the light of the sixth month £8 million loss. If he didn’t, then things at the club are even worse than they appear.

Popular

Maybe he has looked at the way other team’s fans view the likes of Sir Alex Ferguson, Arsene Wenger and Jose Mourinho and realised that he was far to universally popular to be successful. He has decided that the only way to achieve success is by getting the fans of all other clubs to dislike you. If that is the case, he is doing a pretty good job of it!

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Graham Fisher


SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • Brad Lovell

    0 0

    u must be a chelsea fan, chencha. i imagine u talkin in a depressed sort of way.
    but yeah, cfc has stumbled too much in the past month, and now Man United (wo hoo!) are up front. crap i forget where liverpool is, i need to check the table. I’ll do that now.
    its like i said, cfc are in too much of a tailspin to win the premiership. the way they played gainst hull city makes west brom look capable of beatin them. maybe im exaggeratin here, that shits……

  • Chencha

    0 0

    Chelsea had blow it this time, they have given man united and liverpool a chence to win the lague.

  • Brad Lovell

    0 0

    Chelsea to be premiership champion? femi alex, sumthin wrong with u. chelsea are in a tailspin. scolari been sacked, MU( the team my ancestors were suporters of, and im with em) has crushed cfc 3-0, liverpool left cfc flattened 2-0, and cfc has stumbled gainst hull city 0-0.
    i dont see how cfc will win the champioship, and how Man United (MU) will lose it.
    GLORY GLORY MAN UNITED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Kids Soccer

    0 0

    Keane was dynamite for Tottenham and never really given a chance at Liverpool. Scored 3 goals in 2 games and then benched for no apparent reason, never to play again. I second Benitez is losing it. No silverware this year and your time is up.

  • femi alex aderotoye

    0 0

    i beleive chelsea is going to be crown premiership champion, because they are going through building process

  • Dylan

    0 0

    As a avid Liverpool fan myself, I defiantly am a little confused about some of the choices Rafa makes in his squad. However, did not Benayoun, for example, have two solid shots on Cech even though he was substituted in during the 74th minute? Also, Kuyt defiantly isn’t the strongest player on the pitch but his work rate and determination are unmatched, probably in all of Europe. Besides, I don’t know a Liverpool supporter who doesn’t love seeing Kuyt on the pitch, especially since Babel hasn’t fully bloomed as a player yet. And I just have to put this in here, Torres is Back!

  • FRANCO

    0 0

    I am not suroprised at your attack on Benitez. Frankly, Robbie Keane was a good player with Totenham but, sadly, was just not good enough at Liverpool. Torres teriffic run in his very first season, now also Robinho, shows that great players adapt fast and show theri real worth sooner rather than later. Keane just cant take the pressure that being a top striker with Liverpool brings. Sadly, the English press and you ignore the premises and undully attack Benitez after his statements of facts against Britain only top four manager, Sir Alex. I used to wonder why EUFA and FIFA dont tend to call and rely on English referees for their competitions, now i know. Those of us abroad, clearly see the facts as presented by Benitez and totally support him. Get stuffed.

  • justin

    0 0

    It’s a weird situation because I feel that (as a fan) Benitez has been trying to get Keane away since the day that he came. Benitez is one of the most tactically gifted managers in the game, but I think that he got it all wrong with Keano. He had him playing as a main striker when everyone knew from his days at spurs that he was best playing just off the shoulder of the main striker. Also, Keane’s “replacement” David N’gog is nowhere near the level of Keane and I think Rafa made a massive mistake in selling Keane. Torres is injury prone, and if he gets injured again, evem for two weeks, LFC are gunna have a very big problem. In full tho, I agree that the situation at Anfield is very strange right now.

  • Gareth

    0 0

    It was strange, i dont agree with it personally, but I suppose Spurs would have only paid what they paid for him now, not again at the end of the season.

  • Graham Fisher

    0 0

    Thanks for the info Gareth. I agree that a £3 million loss is considerably better than an £8 million loss. Having said that, it still seems slightly strange.

  • Gareth

    0 0

    Liverpool had only paid 11.6 million of the 18.7 million transfer fee for Keane. Add ons and bonus payments took it over 20 mil. Keane was sold back for 16million pounds. Thats only a loss of just under 3million pounds..

  • Gareth

    0 0

    Liverpool had only paid 11.6 million of the 18.7 million transfer fee for Keane. Add ons and bonus payments took it over 20 mil. Keane was sold back for 16million pounds. Thats only a loss of just under 3million pounds..

  • Graham Fisher

    0 0

    Thanks for the info Gareth. I agree that a £3 million loss is considerably better than an £8 million loss. Having said that, it still seems slightly strange.

  • Gareth

    0 0

    It was strange, i dont agree with it personally, but I suppose Spurs would have only paid what they paid for him now, not again at the end of the season.

  • justin

    0 0

    It’s a weird situation because I feel that (as a fan) Benitez has been trying to get Keane away since the day that he came. Benitez is one of the most tactically gifted managers in the game, but I think that he got it all wrong with Keano. He had him playing as a main striker when everyone knew from his days at spurs that he was best playing just off the shoulder of the main striker. Also, Keane’s “replacement” David N’gog is nowhere near the level of Keane and I think Rafa made a massive mistake in selling Keane. Torres is injury prone, and if he gets injured again, evem for two weeks, LFC are gunna have a very big problem. In full tho, I agree that the situation at Anfield is very strange right now.

  • FRANCO

    0 0

    I am not suroprised at your attack on Benitez. Frankly, Robbie Keane was a good player with Totenham but, sadly, was just not good enough at Liverpool. Torres teriffic run in his very first season, now also Robinho, shows that great players adapt fast and show theri real worth sooner rather than later. Keane just cant take the pressure that being a top striker with Liverpool brings. Sadly, the English press and you ignore the premises and undully attack Benitez after his statements of facts against Britain only top four manager, Sir Alex. I used to wonder why EUFA and FIFA dont tend to call and rely on English referees for their competitions, now i know. Those of us abroad, clearly see the facts as presented by Benitez and totally support him. Get stuffed.

  • Dylan

    0 0

    As a avid Liverpool fan myself, I defiantly am a little confused about some of the choices Rafa makes in his squad. However, did not Benayoun, for example, have two solid shots on Cech even though he was substituted in during the 74th minute? Also, Kuyt defiantly isn’t the strongest player on the pitch but his work rate and determination are unmatched, probably in all of Europe. Besides, I don’t know a Liverpool supporter who doesn’t love seeing Kuyt on the pitch, especially since Babel hasn’t fully bloomed as a player yet. And I just have to put this in here, Torres is Back!

  • femi alex aderotoye

    0 0

    i beleive chelsea is going to be crown premiership champion, because they are going through building process

  • Kids Soccer

    0 0

    Keane was dynamite for Tottenham and never really given a chance at Liverpool. Scored 3 goals in 2 games and then benched for no apparent reason, never to play again. I second Benitez is losing it. No silverware this year and your time is up.

  • Brad Lovell

    0 0

    Chelsea to be premiership champion? femi alex, sumthin wrong with u. chelsea are in a tailspin. scolari been sacked, MU( the team my ancestors were suporters of, and im with em) has crushed cfc 3-0, liverpool left cfc flattened 2-0, and cfc has stumbled gainst hull city 0-0.
    i dont see how cfc will win the champioship, and how Man United (MU) will lose it.
    GLORY GLORY MAN UNITED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Chencha

    0 0

    Chelsea had blow it this time, they have given man united and liverpool a chence to win the lague.

  • Brad Lovell

    0 0

    u must be a chelsea fan, chencha. i imagine u talkin in a depressed sort of way.
    but yeah, cfc has stumbled too much in the past month, and now Man United (wo hoo!) are up front. crap i forget where liverpool is, i need to check the table. I’ll do that now.
    its like i said, cfc are in too much of a tailspin to win the premiership. the way they played gainst hull city makes west brom look capable of beatin them. maybe im exaggeratin here, that shits……

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

More More
Top