Ivan Toney’s career trajectory has taken a dramatic turn over the past 18 months. Once a prolific striker for Brentford and a rising star in the England setup, Toney shocked many by leaving the Premier League for Saudi Arabia in the summer of 2024. His £40 million move to Al-Ahli was one of the headline transfers of that window, signaling both the growing allure of the Saudi Pro League and the financial incentives that lured top talent away from Europe.
Now, as the January transfer window approaches, speculation about his return to England is intensifying, driven by his form abroad and the looming 2026 World Cup.
Life in Saudi Arabia: Success and Challenges
Toney’s time in Saudi Arabia has been nothing short of prolific. Since joining Al-Ahli, he has scored 41 goals and provided eight assists in 59 appearances, cementing his status as one of the league’s standout performers. His first season yielded 30 goals in 44 matches, earning him a recall to the England squad under Thomas Tuchel. Despite limited minutes—just two in a friendly against Senegal—his international ambitions remain alive, though increasingly contingent on a return to Europe’s top leagues.
The move, however, came with trade-offs. While Toney enjoys a lucrative contract reportedly worth £400,000 per week after tax (rising to £500,000 with bonuses), this financial windfall has created a major obstacle for any Premier League comeback.
Clubs would need to offer close to £900,000 per week to match his Saudi earnings with UK taxes included—a figure few are willing to entertain.
Premier League Interest: Who’s in the Race?
Despite the financial hurdles, several Premier League clubs have expressed interest in bringing Toney back. Everton, Tottenham Hotspur, and West Ham are said to be among those monitoring his situation. Spurs, in particular, appear keen, driven by injuries to key forwards and the prospect of reuniting Toney with Thomas Frank, the manager who transformed him into a top-flight striker at Brentford.
Former Spurs player David Bentley has publicly endorsed the move, calling Tottenham the “perfect destination” for Toney to revive his England hopes.
Manchester United, once linked with Toney before his Saudi switch, could also re-enter the fray amid struggles with summer signing Benjamin Sesko. However, United’s recent investments and squad depth make a January move less likely. West Ham, battling relegation and desperate for goals, have reportedly explored a loan deal, though covering Toney’s wages remains a sticking point.
The England Factor: World Cup Looms Large
Toney’s motivation for a Premier League return is not solely financial—it’s strategic. With the 2026 World Cup on the horizon, he knows that playing in Europe’s elite leagues is crucial to catching Tuchel’s eye.
England’s striker pool beyond Harry Kane is thin, and Toney’s proven ability to score in the Premier League makes him an attractive option. Yet, his absence from recent squads underscores the risk: staying in Saudi Arabia could cost him a World Cup berth.
Financial and Logistical Barriers
The biggest impediment to any deal is money. Toney’s salary, combined with Saudi tax penalties for early departure, makes a January move improbable unless Al-Ahli agrees to subsidize wages or a creative loan arrangement emerges.
Even then, Premier League clubs must weigh whether short-term gains justify such a hefty outlay, especially when Champions League qualification or survival hangs in the balance.
Toney’s Perspective: A Calculated Gamble
Publicly, Toney has maintained that he does not miss the Premier League and is focused on performing well wherever he plays. Yet, reports suggest he is open to returning, particularly to Tottenham, where he could thrive in Frank’s system as he had done before.
His comments about adapting to different cultures and enjoying the Saudi experience hint at a player comfortable abroad—but ambition for international football may ultimately tip the scales.
Conclusion: A Saga to Watch
Ivan Toney’s story encapsulates the modern football dilemma: balancing financial security with competitive ambition. His success in Saudi Arabia proves his quality, but the Premier League remains the stage for global recognition and England selection.
Whether a January move materializes depends on complex negotiations and Toney’s willingness to sacrifice earnings for opportunity. For now, the whispers of a homecoming add intrigue to a transfer window already brimming with drama.
- Soccer News Like
- Be the first of your friends!
