Thursday, May 2, 2024

Were has it all gone wrong for Manchester United?

Manchester United suffered a 2-1 defeat at Swiss side Basel last night and were dumped out the Champions League.

There wasn’t any doubt before the tie in Switzerland that United could get through because of the perceived gulf in class.

Embarrassed

Manchester United left-back Patrice Evra stated after the game that he felt embarrassed by the teams performance and I’m sure a lot of his teammates are feeling the same way.

Basel are a decent side but nobody expected United to struggle to beat them in either of their encounters.

Midfield

As we all know Manchester United have had problems in the centre of the park. United started with a midfield three of Park Ji-Sung, Phil Jones and Ryan Giggs. I wouldn’t say any of those players are actually central midfielders.

Giggs has had to revert to the centre of the park because he hasn’t got the pace to play on the wing anymore. Young Phil Jones will no doubt become a great player but at the end of the day he’s probably going to end up a centre-back.

And I’d say Park Ji-Sung is also a wide player. That’s where the South Korean has been most effective in recent years anyway. All three are decent players but they are not the quality of central midfielder Manchester United need.

Like lots of people during the summer I questioned United boss Sir Alex Ferguson’s decision not to sign a central midfielder. I really thought he had something up his sleeve. It turns out he didn’t and United are now struggling in the centre of the park.

The Manchester United midfielder can usual cope against weaker teams in all competitions but they have been exposed in recent weeks. United can’t rely on young midfield Tom Cleverley to provide the solution to his problems because he is currently injured and could be for sometime yet.

I’m sure United boss Sir Alex Ferguson will now be looking to strengthen his central midfield area in January, he really has to if the club are going to turn the season around.

Defence

The United defence looked very shaky against Basel, especially when Nemanja Vidic went off injured. I don’t believe that Jonny Evans is good enough for Manchester United. He just hasn’t got the class that is required from someone playing for one of the biggest clubs in the world.

Rio Ferdinand is also looking really poor at the moment. At 33 years of age he isn’t getting any younger and he is starting to show it. Sir Alex Ferguson has brought in the likes of youngsters Chris Smalling and Phil Jones but neither have spent much time at centre-back.

Both these youngsters have immense potential but lack experience because they are being played out of position at full-back or central midfield. They are not going to fulfil their potential as centre-backs if they never actually play in the position.

Turnaround

I recently wrote an article about not writing Manchester United off. And I will stick to that but questions will be asked about what is currently going wrong at Old Trafford. I’m sure United boss Sir Alex Ferguson won’t panic though, he is too experienced for that and somehow try to turn the season around.

What is going wrong at Manchester United?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Nugent


David is a freelance football writer with nearly a decade of experience writing about the beautiful game. The experienced writer has written for over a dozen websites and also an international soccer magazine offline.
Arguably his best work has come as an editorial writer for Soccernews, sharing his good, bad and ugly opinions on the world’s favourite sport. During David’s writing career he has written editorials, betting previews, match previews, banter, news and opinion pieces.

SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • Brad

    0 0

    Russ, he should be transferred to a smaller club. It’s too much of a risk having him play, let alone start, for United. I agree with Sam, Fergie keeps saying he’s happy with his current squad, but that was before Vidic’s injury. Couple that with our complete lack of a center midfield, and Smalling seemingly not well suited to being a right back (example A being today’s match against Wolves), even SAF has to go look for someone.

  • russ ru

    0 0

    fergie’s chopping and changing of the team has really messed up the chemistry of the squad. The young team that beat man city in e community shield and won so convincingly at the start of the season hasn’t been kept together. By tryin to bring in the older players we looked shaky and we paid for that. Evra is now complacent, make him compete with fabio. Lindegaard is Way better than De gea right now. Jones is decent in midfield but better at the back. Prefer fletcher to carrick in the middle as he can score the odd goal. Evans should play on the flanks or not at all!

  • Sam

    0 0

    I think the problem is definitely in the centre of midfield. Carrick, Park or giggs just don’t cut it. Cleverley will be good but needs time. Unfortunatley for United these midfield problems coupled with Vidic being out for the season spells trouble. I sense a bit of spending in January

  • Sam

    0 0

    I think the problem is definitely in the centre of midfield. Carrick, Park or giggs just don’t cut it. Cleverley will be good but needs time. Unfortunatley for United these midfield problems coupled with Vidic being out for the season spells trouble. I sense a bit of spending in January

  • russ ru

    0 0

    fergie’s chopping and changing of the team has really messed up the chemistry of the squad. The young team that beat man city in e community shield and won so convincingly at the start of the season hasn’t been kept together. By tryin to bring in the older players we looked shaky and we paid for that. Evra is now complacent, make him compete with fabio. Lindegaard is Way better than De gea right now. Jones is decent in midfield but better at the back. Prefer fletcher to carrick in the middle as he can score the odd goal. Evans should play on the flanks or not at all!

  • Brad

    0 0

    Russ, he should be transferred to a smaller club. It’s too much of a risk having him play, let alone start, for United. I agree with Sam, Fergie keeps saying he’s happy with his current squad, but that was before Vidic’s injury. Couple that with our complete lack of a center midfield, and Smalling seemingly not well suited to being a right back (example A being today’s match against Wolves), even SAF has to go look for someone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

Live Scores

advertisement

Betting Guide Advertisement

advertisement

Become a Writer
More More
Top